Best Restaurants of 2025
voted by Morgantown locals
Winners have finally debuted on the FOURTH Annual 'Top Dish' Restaurant List! Local foodies voted for their favorite places to dine, drink, and gather - here's your 2025 Best Restaurants in Morgantown. Our top 2 contenders will compete for Hall of Fame status in 2026 if a stand-out star doesn’t make their way to the top next year.
Tied: Table 9 & Village Butcher
Village Butcher is new to the Top Dish list but has been making waves in Star City since 2021. I personally testify that they have the best burger in Morgantown. Speaking of burgers, Table 9 has burger night specials every Tuesday.
Tied: Iron Horse & Lefty’s Place
Don’t let ties fool you - Lefty’s Place has been on the Top Dish list every single year since 2022! For good reason, too - their weirdly sweet and totally addictive french fries and ranch dressing are legendary. So is the voodoo wing sauce.
Second: Von Blaze
An upset! Von Blaze Sandwiches in downtown Morgantown has won first place the last two years in a row.
WINNER: Black Bear Burritos
Black Bear Burritos in Evansdale has made the Top Dish list every year and kicked off the first-ever vote in 2022 with first place!